The Crescent Report

November 5, 2007

Destroying Democracy in Pakistan in Not an Option

Filed under: Pakistan — Tags: , , — Imam Mahdi Bray @ 11:14 pm

 A Note From Imam Mahdi BrayThe recent declaration of emergency law by Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf , which in effect ensures he is in complete control over all aspects of Pakistani society, is a tragic turn of events that should be condemned by all people of good faith. He stated that he implemented martial-law as a means of doing whatever is necessary to “save Pakistan” and he has even compared himself to Abe Lincoln. Perhaps a more accurate comparison for Musharaff is not Lincoln; but Hosni Mubarak , Mobu Sese Se, Robert Mugabe, or any other second-rate dictator who wants to remain in power indefinitely  would be more appropriate, but Lincoln? As my 5 year old would say “gimme a break”! What Musharaff is actually doing is silencing his opposition, extending his dictatorial grab on power, and moving Pakistan closer and close to a failed state.

Below is the commentary of Ibrahim Ramey the Director of MAS Freedom Foundation Civil and Human Rights Division.

Destroying Democracy in Pakistan in Not an Option 

As I write this commentary, Pakistan is imploding. 

General/President/dictator  Pervez Musharraf has suspended the constitution of the nation.  The supreme court, and parliament, have both been dissolved.  Martial law has been declared, and more than 1,500 political opposition leaders, lawyers, and judges have been arrested.  Thousands of citizens are battling police in the streets of Islamabad, and other cities across the country. 

The chaos of constitutional crisis and autocracy now verge on catastrophe.  And this I a catastrophe in an unstable nuclear weapons state that, if left unadressed,  could spiral into the virtual disintegration of the nation itself. 

All dictators have their own made-for-mass-consumption reasons for attempting to squash the fundamental democratic rights of their own people.  In the case of General Musharraf, the big, public card in his geopolitical hand is the (alleged) war against Islamic “extremists” in the remote northwest area of his nation.  This is, of course, the primary glue that binds Pakistan to the global “war against terror” led and orchestrated by the U.S.   

It’s also the single most important factor in maintaining the personal relationship between General Musharraf and the ruling circles of the U.S. government, including

his personal relationships with President Bush and Vice-President Cheyney, who guarantee the unrestricted flow of money and weapons to their Pakistani “ally”. 

But this time, the General may have overplayed his “anti-terrorism” hand by his brutal attempt to end any semblance of real democratic rule in Pakistan.  By dismantling the national judiciary and throwing hundreds of political opponents in jail, he is saying, in effect, that any challenge to his autocratic rule only emboldens the supporters of Al Queda and the Taliban. 

Is it in the national interest of the United States to tolerate Musharraf’s attempt to destroy is opposition, and the democratic institutions of his country?  The answer is an emphatic NO.  If left unchecked, the current crackdown will only result in a bloody civil conflict in Pakistan, and possibly even civil war.  If this happens, there is no guarantee that the entire Pakistani military will remain loyal to Gen. Musharraf. And any internal rebellion will leave open the unthinkable possibility that the control of Pakistan’s small atomic arsenal might become compromised. 

But a more probable scenario is the diminished possibility of an open, democratic electoral transition to a representative civilian government that is capable of addressing the myriad of divisions and contradictions in Pakistan. And that would leave the business of government to those political elements in Pakistan with the most guns-and the most money behind them. 

It is unthinkable that Muslims, and real democrats of any description, would allow Pakistan to devolve into becoming another Somalia-and in this case, a Somalia with nuclear weapons.  The United States, which has supplied Musharraf with weapons, foreign aid, and international political cover, must not be allowed to remain on the sidelines while things in Pakistan become more bloody and desperate. 

If America truly means what it proclaims to the world about respect for democracy and human rights, it must do now what is absolutely necessary to safeguard both.  One, all military and foreign assistance to the government of Gen, Musharraf must immediately cease.  And two, the U.S. must use all of its power and prestige to persuade Mr. Musharraf to resign from office, and by doing so, end his personal onslaught against popular rule in Pakistan. 

As I have stared previously, it is time for Gen. Musharraf to go.  And that time is now more urgent than ever. 

Ibrahim Ramey


Leave a Comment »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: